The significance of the Oger v Whatcott ruling

On 27 March, the BC Human Rights Tribunal ruled in my favour in my complaint against Bill Whatcott that stemmed from his distribution of flyers containing anti-transgender propaganda and encouraging people to discriminate against me due to my being a transgender woman.

The BC Human Rights Tribunal agreed with me that Bill Whatcott announcing his intention to discriminate and urging others to do the same because I was transgender was a violation of the explicit prohibition from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or expression as it applies to publications, insection 7 of the BC Human Rights Code.

I recorded a short video expressing my thoughts about this groundbreaking ruling that finally tells us all there are limits to our charter rights when it comes to hate propaganda.

The ruling finally confirms that bigots can’t simply hide behind their faith or free expression to publish hate propaganda aimed at inciting discrimination on prohibited grounds.

My thoughts about the ruling that Bill Whatcott was guilty of violating my rights when he published flyers announcing his intention to discriminate against me and urging others to do the same

I hope others in Canada will make use of this ruling to protect themselves from hate propaganda they experience. See also this posting from earlier this week.

Coverage of the Oger v Whatcott Human Rights Tribunal decision in my favour: (Vancouver Sun coverageStar coverageCBC coverage)


3 responses to “The significance of the Oger v Whatcott ruling”

  1. Disinformation online causes hatred on the ground – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] live our lives free of discrimination are equal under the law. This was part of the ruling in the Oger v Whatcott BC Human Rights Tribunal case. Based on my complaint about Bill Whatcott’s discriminatory publication about me, the […]


  2. Oak Bay Anti-SOGI Event Illustrates Need For Booking-Policy Review – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] after ruling have confirmed that Canada’s Charter protections do not extend to inciting hatred or to inciting […]


  3. Transgender rights repeatedly stand in Canadian courts – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] by the cacophony of accusations lacking the slightest substance, but the rights of people to live our lives free of discrimination stand every legal […]


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: