Transgender rights repeatedly stand in Canadian decisions

Discrimination on the basis of gender identity or expression is explicitly prohibited in Canadian law and was recently confirmed in a slew of groundbreaking wins in Canada as anti-LGBT activists lose test after test.

Access to medical care and child abuse

In late February, B.C.’s supreme court ruled in favour of a transgender teen who wanted to access hormone therapy despite his father’s objections, and stated that misgendering and preventing a kid from transitioning could be considered child abuse. Efforts by Kari Simpson and hate group Culture Guard to discredit highly-regarded professionals for simply doing their job might help polarize traditional conservative mindsets held by people who have limited access to facts, but this is not a new phenomenon, not has it been working over the long term beyond funding her lifestyle.

Regardless of the angry blowback from people in the conservative and libertarian fringes, denying a child’s identity on explicitly prohibited grounds or witholding medical care are both recognized to be family abuse against the child in Canada.

As Canadian courts have repeatedly upheld, freedom of expression and freedom of religion do not extend to acts of publishing hate propaganda or othet discrimination against people on the grounds of explicitly prohibited discrimination.

Hate propaganda

Vancouver Sun Article: Anti-gay activist ordered to pay $55,000 to B.C. trans candidate in fight over hateful flyer
Vancouver sun: “The three-person tribunal ruled that Whatcott had discriminated against Oger based solely on her gender.”

As BC Human Rights Tribunal member Cousineau recently noted in its Oger v Whatcott ruling upholding gender identity as an explicitly-prohibited grounds of discrimination in Canada, anti-transgender propaganda “is a modern version of a ‘whites only’ sign” that has no place in a modern democracy such as Canada.

As I noted in my testimony, “I’m a transgender woman. People kill transgender women because of who we are. And they start with this. And it’s impossible to tell whether this is the ramblings of a person who’s likely to do that, or if it’s not. After this flyer came out, I had to worry what Mr. Whatcott looked like, but I also had to worry about other people who maybe gave him credibility.

Discrimination in services

Vancouver Rape Relief’s Hilla Kerner tells the City of Vancouver council members her organization does not let transgender women access all services they make available despite their mandate to support “all women”

Hilla Kerner at Vancouver City Hall confirms Vancouver Rape Relief discriminates in publicly-funded services against women who are transgender

The fury of the extreme-right right social conservative community on discovering that they do not hold Dominion over Canadian society is reflected by the cacophony of accusations lacking the slightest substance, but the rights of people to live our lives free of discrimination stand every legal test.

Maybe it’s time for the ultra conservative groups to reconsider where they stand on inclusion before their cherished organizations collapse from the predictable outcomes of discrimination.

Morgane Oger speaks about faith and transgender living in Kamloops in March 2019 days after winning a groundbreaking human rights case
Morgane Oger speaks about faith and transgender living in Kamloops in March 2019 days after winning a groundbreaking human rights case



3 responses to “Transgender rights repeatedly stand in Canadian decisions”

  1. Vancouver Rape Relief failure to meet Vancouver criteria for program funding shows pressing need to update approach – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] Canada, trans women are women. In B.C., we have been recognized as women since 1999. This is simply not […]


  2. There’s always a second chance for reformed anti-trans activists – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] Barbara Kay, Meghan Murphy, Kari Simpson, Jordan Peterson, Barry Neufeld, Parents United Canada, Culture Guard, Real Women Canada, 3 Percent, Soldiers of Odin, Canadian Christian Lobby, Jenn Smith, Canadian […]


  3. Meghan Murphy you are misleading your audience – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] 1999 has lost. And no, Nixon v. VRR is not precedent for service delivery of employment. Today, transgender rights are being systematically confirmed and your writings present your view as if they were a fact rather than a position contrary to our […]


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: