Oak Bay Anti-SOGI Event Illustrates Need For Booking-Policy Review

On May 2, I was invited by Oak Bay school trustee Ryan Painter to the Victoria, BC suburb of Oak Bay to help the Vancouver Island LGBTQ2+ community, our families, and our friends stand up to a to a campaign to incite discrimination against them and their children organized by Campbell-River based group “Canadian Christian Lobby“, a recently organized anti-LGBT Christian organization with apparent ties to supremacist groups.

The Incitement of hatred and discrimination is a public-safety matter that our provincial and federal governments have to take seriously. Statistics Canada reported a 37% jump in hate-motivated crime in 2016 and another 47% jump in 2017, as reported by Reuters. It is time for us to address the incitement of hatred and discrimination where we can, and it is easy to shut the door to them in municipal and institutional facilities through effective rental policies.

Advertisement poster for a Canadian Christian Lobby – funded tour of Vancouver Island advocating for discrimination against the LGBT community, specifically children.

This group organized a multi-city tour with the intention of amplifying their views inciting the refusal of medical services or anti-bullying services to children on the basis of their LGBTQ2+ status, with an obsessive focus on transgender children and youth.

Ruling after ruling have confirmed that Canada’s Charter protections do not extend to inciting hatred or to inciting discrimination on prohibited grounds. The Charter does not offer any freedom to harm others or to deny anyone their right to participate in society free of discrimination.

Image may contain: 5 people, including Morgane Oger, Randall Garrison, people smiling, people standing, eyeglasses and outdoor
Two persons pose with Randal Garrison and Morgane Oger at the May 2 event protesting the “Erosion of Free Speech” anti-transgender event in Oak Bay
Image may contain: 9 people, people smiling, people standing, hat and outdoor
Hundreds of persons attended the May 2 Oak Bay event

No matter who they are or what they believe, people who incite discrimination on prohibited grounds or express their intention to do so are inciting people to break the law. If they stray into inciting hatred likely to cause a disturbance doing it, they fall under section 319 of the Canadian Criminal Code.

Image may contain: one or more people, crowd and outdoor

Hundreds of persons attended the May 2 Oak Bay event

Municipal councils have been slow to address the growth in hatred in Canada since the Harper government removed section 13 of the Canadian Human Rights Act. Today, hate groups are using municipal facilities to organize events and then broadcast them on the internet with total disregard for the harm they cause, and this needs to be managed. I am counting on Canada’s municipalities and governments to apply the law, just like I am counting on our law enforcement organizations to enforce Canadian law as necessary.

In the spring of 2019, communities on Vancouver Island chose to stand up and speak out against hate, and show their love and support for LGBTQ+ people.
Video: Brad Dirks

In a phone call on May 2, 2019, I urged Oak Bay Mayor Kevin Murdoch asking Oak Bay council to enact event rental policies that let the city reserve the right to deny or cancel a booking as follows when it reasonably believes use by any individual or group will be for a purpose that is likely to promote, or would have the effect of promoting discrimination, contempt or hatred for any group or person on the basis of prohibited grounds. I was please to learn from him that the city had already initiated the process of reviewing its space rental policies as a result of the May 2, 2019 event.

In April 2019, I presented the same advice to the Board of Trustees of the Vancouver Public Library in response to a similar problem which occured in january 2019 when Meghan Murphy booked a space at the VPL Central Branch, also for the purpose of inciting anti-transgender discrimination.

Click here to read the report on the advice I gave to the Trustees.

Image may contain: 5 people, people standing, car and outdoor
Event organizers and volunteers seemed exceedingly unfriendly

Click here for beautiful photos from the Oak Bay protest posted to Facebook.

Related press…

Nanaimo News Bulletin: Protesters try to make anti-SOGI 123 speaker unwelcome in Nanaimo

CBC: Free Speech or Hate Speech? BC district advised not to pull anti-SOGI talk despite protests

Georgia Straight: LGBT-inclusive activists gear up to protest anti-SOGI transgender speaker Jenn Smith on Vancouver Island

Times Colonist: Protestors disrupt anti-SOGI speaker in Oak Bay


7 responses to “Oak Bay Anti-SOGI Event Illustrates Need For Booking-Policy Review”

  1. Dean Cardno Avatar
    Dean Cardno

    It seems that you think anyone should be free to have an opinion, so long as it agrees with yours. Maybe, they should just be free to have an opinion, and express it?


  2. Is Canada Contributing To The UK Anti-Trans Violence? – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] we do know however is that when Canadian universities, municipalities, and public libraries allow people to use their facilities to give credibility to their attempt to […]


  3. Course: governance 101. Grade: F. UBC has much to learn about following its own rules. – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] at length about concerns with Smith inciting discrimination on prohibited grounds. [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] […]


  4. Hatred is a social disease we must address – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] organizations, we are fighting hatred in our institutions. I am fighting it in the courts. I advocate for better rules on how institutions make facilities available to spread hatred. I testified to the House of Commons […]


  5. The Erosion of Decency: Free Expression Has no Room For Inciting Discrimination or Hatred – Morgane Oger Avatar

    […] May 2 2019, conservative faith-based group Canadian Christian Lobby, the CCL, held a public talk entitled “The erosion of freedom: How transgender politics in […]


  6. Jeanette Standerwick Avatar
    Jeanette Standerwick

    The only one discriminated against was Jenn Smith . The hate spewed at a peaceful civil presentation was disgraceful. It will be interesting when the videos become public.
    When are we going to see this debate ?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Morgane Oger Avatar

      Thank you for sharing your opinion.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: